nuseri wrote:Ya Ali madad
The answer to the main topic is going to b incomplete till eternity.
That topic for debate purpose is almost closed like,same n same things is said again n again n again.
My question was related as majority without Imam read n observe Quran at Zahiri level.
The question is important because the new generation who will be educated seek answers to similar nature questions to parents,scholars n Al Waez.
Did you not notice a gen-next question asked by Admin?
I am still laughing over it. His question was well answered by todays scientific study and Quran was not needed for that answer.
Even then, let us each of us answer these 4 questions.
Of course, different people will have different answers to the same questions.
let me try to answer them with my limited knowledge. I am ready to change my views someone else's answers are more convincing to me.
1. Is the Quran complete in all its entirety?
MY ANS: Quran are the words uttered from the mouth of the Prophet.
The Prophet during his life time did not say "now the Quran is complete so i no longer will be delivering you the messages" or something to that effect.
If he did, then please, somebody should correct me.
2. Have parts been left out from it?
MY ANS: I strongly believe that the Prophet revealed what was supposed to be revealed.
053:001 By the Star when it plunges,
053:002 your comrade is not astray, neither errs,
053:003 nor speaks he out of caprice.
053:004 This is naught but a revelation revealed,
053:005 taught him by one Mighty in power,
3. Are all the messages in the Quran universal? Or were some of the messages applicable to that period of time in that specific context?
MY ANS: I dont know. On a Zaheri level, it might look so but then then we are batinis.
How ever sunnis do claim that some verses was time bounded, but then they understand verses on zaheri level only.......
they call it abrogated verses and they quote the below two verses to support their theory of Abrogated Verses.
002:106 And for whatever verse We abrogate or cast into oblivion, We bring a better or the like of it; know you not that God is powerful over everything?
016:101 And when We exchange a verse in the place of another verse and God knows very well what He is sending down -- they say, 'You are a mere forger!' Nay, but the most of them have no knowledge.
This theory Abrogated Verses was put by sunis, i think, because they could not answer as to how some verses were contradicting to each other and at at the same time Quran is claiming to contradiction-free revelation.
004:082 What, do they not ponder the Koran? If it had been from other than God surely they would have found in it much inconsistency.
4. Does it even matter if Quran is or isn't complete since we have a Hazar Imam as our present living Quran?
MY ANS: Since we have a Hazar Imam as our present living Quran, we have complete Quran.